The documents below form the evidentiary backbone of this case. Each one is a matter of public record. Click any card to open the PDF.
Title to Maui Properties
Kirk's title report — a historical record by a licensed real estate attorney, proving Kimberly quit-claimed her rights in 2001.
Dow Patten Research Letter
Attorney Dow Patten confirms Kimberly could not redeem — doing so would violate two Hawaii laws. Cites Serion v. Thornton.
Full Deposition by Kimberly Caspillo
Kimberly admits she never hired Matson Kelley and never knew him. Read pages 72–76 for the key admissions.
Letters from Paul Horikawa
Demand letter to buy back property for Julia, followed by a retraction nine days later — cancelling the notice to redeem.
Quitclaim Deed
Signed by Kimberly — paid $10 by HieHie, LLC, owned by Matson Kelly.
Kimberly's Affidavit
The so-called affidavit that allegedly proves Kimberly was Moana's sole heir.
Assignment of Interest
"Assignment of Interest in Real Property" — claims Kimberly was paid $10,000 by HieHie, LLC.
Private Investigator Invoice
Invoice from Steve Goodenow to Matson Kelly ($3,699.67) to locate Kimberly — proof she never hired him. Dated Feb 19, 2015.
Matson Kelly's First Letter
The first threatening letter sent by Matson Kelly, filled with misrepresentations. Dated Feb 24, 2015.
Matson Kelly's Second Letter
The follow-up threatening letter. Dated March 6, 2015.
Andrew Chianese Letter
Letter from Andrew Chianese, the honest young attorney who discovered the evidence that exposed the fraud.